# Values for Games without Sidepayments: Some Difficulties with Current Concepts

https://doi.org/0012-9682(198003)48:2<457:VFGWSS>2.0.CO;2-E
p. 457-466

Alvin E. Roth

Two solution concepts for games without sidepayments are considered: the stable bargaining solution proposed by Harsanyi[6, 7], and the $\lambda$-transfer value first proposed by Shapley [19]. Some examples of games are considered for which both solution concepts yield results which are highly counter-intuitive, and which seem to be inconsistent with the hypothesis that the games are played by rational players.